February 13, 2026
Alito memoir timing and legacy book fuel pre-midterm retirement speculation
October book release date, Hemingway biography, and Politico interview signal strategic exit
February 13, 2026
October book release date, Hemingway biography, and Politico interview signal strategic exit
Justice
Samuel Alito turns 76 on April 1, 2026. He was confirmed to the Supreme Court on Jan. 31, 2006, making 2026 his 20th year on the bench. Alito is the second-most conservative justice after Clarence Thomas, 77. Both justices face pressure to retire while Republicans control the Senate to ensure conservative replacements serve for decades.
Alito's memoir is scheduled for release on Oct. 6, 2026, one day after the Supreme Court's 2026-2027 term begins on Oct. 5. By comparison, Justice Amy Coney Barrett published her book on Sept. 9, 2025, Justice Neil Gorsuch on May 5, 2025, and Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson in early September before her first full term. The timing allows justices to promote their books when they're not hearing oral arguments. Alito's October release date suggests he doesn't expect to be busy with court duties.
Mollie Hemingway's book 'Alito: The Justice Who Reshaped the Supreme Court and Restored the Constitution' is described by the publisher as 'the authoritative—and explosive—inside story of Justice
Samuel Alito and his powerful role in shaping the Supreme Court.' Legal analysts say such authorized biographies typically require extensive cooperation from the subject, including interviews and access to personal papers. The hagiographic tone and timing suggest a coordinated legacy-building campaign.
In a rare interview with Politico published in January 2026, Alito reflected on his tenure and identified the Dobbs decision overturning Roe v. Wade as his finest achievement. He told Politico he wished Justice Antonin Scalia were around to take a victory lap because 'the court has achieved so much of what he worked toward.' He also complained about 'the coarse civic culture of our current moment,' suggesting dissatisfaction with his current role.
Conservative legal commentators published laudatory articles celebrating Alito's 20th anniversary on the Court in January 2026. Legal experts Dahlia Lithwick and Mark Joseph Stern described these articles as having 'a distinctly valedictory feel,' suggesting coordination among former clerks and conservative legal movement figures. The articles praised Alito's jurisprudence and treated his tenure as a completed body of work rather than an ongoing career.
The 2026 midterm elections on Nov. 5 could shift Senate control to Democrats, making Supreme Court confirmations difficult or impossible. Republicans currently hold 53 Senate seats. If Alito retires by July 2026, Trump and the Republican Senate would have four months to confirm a replacement before the midterms. Democrats forced through Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson's confirmation in April 2022 when Justice Stephen Breyer retired strategically before the midterms.
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg died on Sept. 18, 2020, just weeks before the presidential election, allowing Trump to appoint Amy Coney Barrett. Ginsburg's death at 87 while Democrats lacked Senate control became a cautionary tale for strategic retirement timing. Legal analysts note that Alito appears determined to avoid Ginsburg's fate by retiring on his own terms while his ideological allies control the confirmation process.
Associate Justice of the Supreme Court (2006-present)
Conservative journalist, Federalist senior editor
President of the United States (2025-present)
Legal analyst, Slate senior editor
Legal analyst, Slate senior correspondent
Legal analyst, The Nation justice correspondent