DOJ moves to erase Jan 6 seditious conspiracy convictions
Pirro signs motion to erase 12 seditious conspiracy convictions
Pirro signs motion to erase 12 seditious conspiracy convictions
On April 14, 2026, the Department of Justice filed motions with the DC Circuit Court of Appeals asking judges to vacate the seditious conspiracy convictions of 12 Capitol rioters PBS NewsHour. The filing, signed by Assistant U.S. Attorney Daniel Lenerz in U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro's office, said prosecution "is not in the interests of justice." The motion cited 28 U.S.C. § 2106 and Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 48(a) as legal authority. Pirro became U.S. Attorney for DC after Senate confirmation on August 2, 2025, by a 50-45 vote. She previously worked as a Fox News host and served as Westchester County District Attorney. Juries convicted these defendants after lengthy trials with extensive evidence of advance planning and weapons stockpiling.
Essential concepts and terms to understand this topic
A federal crime punishing agreement to oppose the government by force
The President's authority to forgive federal crimes and reduce sentences, with limited exceptions.
The norm that federal prosecutors make charging decisions based on evidence and law, not political direction from elected officials.
Citizens must approve serious criminal charges before trial starts.
A court order that cancels or voids a previous judgment or conviction
Senate proceedings to convict or acquit impeached federal officials
The authority of prosecutors to decide whether to bring charges and pursue cases
Constitutional procedure to expel an official before their term ends
Geographic location where a legal case is heard or a crime is prosecuted
A legal doctrine that bars the government from bringing charges to punish someone for exercising a constitutional right.
Constitutional bar preventing anyone who engaged in insurrection from holding office
Cannot be tried twice for the same crime by the same government
U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia
Signed the April 2026 vacatur motions. Confirmed by Senate 50-45 in August 2025. Former Fox News host and Westchester County District Attorney. Her office moved to dismiss charges against Trump adviser Stephen Bannon.
Oath Keepers founder
Yale Law School graduate. Sentenced to 18 years for seditious conspiracy. Judge Mehta called his conduct "terrorism." Coordinated the Capitol attack from outside the building. His conviction targeted in the vacatur motion.
Proud Boys chairman
Received the longest January 6 sentence at 22 years. Pardoned January 20, 2025. His conviction was later vacated separately before the April 14 batch motion. Was not physically present at the Capitol but coordinated via encrypted communications.
Oath Keepers member
Sentenced to 12 years for seditious conspiracy. Convicted of coordinating with Rhodes and militia leadership. His conviction targeted in the April 2026 vacatur motion.
Proud Boys leader
Sentenced to 18 years for seditious conspiracy. Coordinated Proud Boys activities on January 6. Posted on X after the vacatur motion, saying he was "beyond thrilled."
U.S. District Judge
Sentenced Rhodes and oversaw Oath Keepers trials. Called seditious conspiracy "among the most serious crimes an individual American can commit." Warned against attempts to "rewrite" January 6 history. Imposed terrorism enhancement.
U.S. District Judge
Oversaw Proud Boys trials and sentenced Tarrio to 22 years. Noted the "importance of the peaceful transfer of power." Expressed concern about efforts to downplay Capitol violence.

Former chief of DOJ Capitol Siege Section
Resigned in June 2025 protesting Trump clemency actions. Called the vacatur motion proof that "political violence is acceptable as long as your politics align." Noted the 100% conviction rate in jury trials under Biden DOJ.

Proud Boys member
Sentenced to 17 years for seditious conspiracy. Convicted of coordinating militia-style planning with Tarrio and others. His conviction targeted in the April 2026 vacatur motion.

Proud Boys member
Sentenced to 15 years for seditious conspiracy. Convicted of coordinating with Proud Boys leaders. His conviction targeted in the April 2026 vacatur motion.

Senate Minority Leader
Condemned the pardons and vacatur efforts on the Senate floor. Said Trump's actions tell people "you want to attack our democracy? Be my guest." Criticized the reversal of jury verdicts.

President of the United States
Issued commutations for seditious conspiracy defendants on January 20, 2025. His administration now seeks vacatur through DOJ motions. The shift from clemency to prosecutorial dismissal reflects administration priorities.
Oath Keepers member
One of the few female seditious conspiracy defendants. Sentenced for coordination with Rhodes and other militia leaders. Conviction targeted in the April 2026 vacatur motion.
Oath Keepers member
Acquitted on seditious conspiracy but convicted on other Capitol breach charges. Some of his convictions may be affected by the broader motion.
Disputed
The DOJ investigation into January 6 was purely political and the convictions were unjust.
Defense attorneys called the prosecutions 'misuse' of seditious conspiracy. But juries convicted all defendants after reviewing extensive evidence of advance planning, weapons stockpiling, and coordination. Judge Mehta found Rhodes's conduct met the legal definition of terrorism. The 100% conviction rate suggests the evidence was strong, not that the cases were political.
Sources
False
Seditious conspiracy charges were overreach because January 6 was just a protest that got out of hand.
UC Davis Law Professor Carlton Larson called the charge 'perfectly pitched to the gravity of the offenses.' Evidence showed Oath Keepers stockpiled guns in a Virginia hotel for a 'quick reaction force,' coordinated movements via encrypted communications, and planned to stop the peaceful transfer of power. This wasn't spontaneous.
Sources
False
Vacating these convictions means the defendants were innocent.
Vacatur erases the legal record of conviction but doesn't address the underlying facts. Juries found these defendants guilty beyond reasonable doubt. The DOJ's motion is based on prosecutorial discretion, not new evidence of innocence. The government isn't claiming the convictions were wrong. It's claiming prosecution isn't in the 'interests of justice.'
Sources
True
Over 140 police officers were injured during the January 6 Capitol riot.
Capitol Police and Metropolitan Police Department records confirm over 140 officers sustained injuries during the January 6 attack, including concussions, chemical burns, and broken bones.
Sources
True
No previous administration has moved to vacate its own successful seditious conspiracy convictions.
Legal scholars and DOJ historians found no modern precedent for the government successfully prosecuting seditious conspiracy, winning jury convictions, and then moving to vacate those convictions. This appears to be the first time in modern history.
Sources
Misleading
Prosecutorial discretion means DOJ can do whatever it wants with cases.
Prosecutors have broad discretion under Rule 48(a), but they need court permission to dismiss charges. Courts rarely block these motions, but judges can question the reasoning. The real check is political, not legal. Senators confirm U.S. Attorneys and can hold oversight hearings.
Sources
Contact your senators about DOJ prosecutorial independence
civic action
The Senate confirms the U.S. Attorney who signed these motions. Senators can hold oversight hearings on whether DOJ's decision to vacate jury-convicted seditious conspiracy cases reflects legitimate prosecutorial discretion or political interference.
Read the DOJ court filings and judge sentencing statements
research
The actual court filings show the DOJ's legal reasoning and the judges' original sentencing statements. Comparing what Judge Mehta said at sentencing with what DOJ now says reveals how prosecutorial priorities shifted between administrations.
Track the DC Circuit's response to the vacatur motions
research
The DC Circuit must approve the vacatur. While courts rarely block prosecutorial dismissals, judges have expressed concern about rewriting January 6 history. Watch for any judicial pushback or conditions attached to the vacatur.