Skip to main content

May 31, 2024

Courts undercut Sixth Amendment rights

Defendants jailed 7+ days without public defenders in Oregon

James MadisonJames Madison pushed the Sixth Amendment in 1789 to check prosecutorial power and protect accused people from secret processes.

Betts v. Brady in 1942 let states refuse routine appointment of counsel and left poor defendants exposed in many counties.

Marginalized defendants and civil-rights fighters demanded counsel and basic confrontation rights through the mid-20th century and met institutional resistance.

Gideon v. Wainwright on Mar. 18, 1963 reversed Betts and forced states to provide lawyers, but Strickland v. Washington on May 14, 1984 set a high bar to prove ineffective assistance.

The same swing between expansion and contraction recurs in Barker v. Wingo (1972), Strickland (1984) and Shinn v. Ramirez (May 23, 2022) when national priorities or budget limits shift.

In 2024 the 9th U.S. Circuit flagged Oregon’s public defense collapse and ordered releases, and in 2025 California appeals courts tossed cases for trial-stacking delays, showing backlog becomes a constitutional harm.

Today underfunded counties and prosecutors win bargaining power; jailed people, victims and mentally ill defendants lose timely justice.

The next battle is unfolding in state legislatures, appellate courts and the Supreme Court over enforceable speedy-trial deadlines and rules for remote testimony.

📜Constitutional Law🎓Education

People, bills, and sources

James Madison

James Madison

Framer and member of the First Congress

Clarence Earl Gideon

Petitioner

Justice Hugo Black

Associate Justice, U.S. Supreme Court

Justice Owen Roberts

Justice Owen Roberts

Associate Justice, U.S. Supreme Court

Justice Sandra Day O'Connor

Associate Justice, U.S. Supreme Court

Justice Clarence Thomas

Justice Clarence Thomas

Associate Justice, U.S. Supreme Court

9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals

Federal appellate court

Brooke Jenkins

San Francisco district attorney

Brenna Bird

Iowa attorney general

American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU)

Advocacy organization

National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (NACDL)

Trade and advocacy organization

Oregon Public Defender and other state PD offices

Public defense agencies

What you can do

1

understanding

Study Supreme Court tests and doctrines that limit this right

Learn the Barker speedy-trial factors, the Strickland ineffective-assistance two-part test, and recent limits from Shinn v. Ramirez so you can spot when your rights are being narrowed.

2

learning more

Follow constitutional law experts and litigation centers

Track live cases and amicus briefs to see how judges apply Sixth Amendment rules and which circuits are enforcing deadlines.

3

practicing

Practice know-your-rights scripts and documentation steps before arrests or court encounters

Memorize how to request counsel immediately, record time stamps, demand a speedy trial and refuse to answer without a lawyer; keep copies of court orders and continuances.

4

civic action

File official complaints and oversight requests when public defenders are unavailable

Use state executive oversight offices, judicial conduct complaints or federal habeas petitions to document systemic denial of counsel and force remedies.

5

civic action

Use legal remedies like Section 1983 suits and class actions to seek systemic change

When courts or officials detain people without counsel or repeatedly miss trial deadlines, civil rights lawyers can file 42 U.S.C. §1983 suits or seek classwide habeas relief to obtain court-enforced reforms.

6

civic action

Join and pressure local advocacy groups to demand funding and enforceable timelines

Local organizing and voter pressure on county commissions and state legislatures compel budget fixes, staffing for public defenders and statutory speedy-trial deadlines.