Trump attacks California Proposition 50 while pushing Texas Republicans to redraw districts
President threatens executive action against state ballot measure
President Trump wrote on Truth Social on Nov. 4, 2025, that California Proposition 50 should be under a "very serious legal and criminal review." White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters on Nov. 4 that the White House was "looking into" executive action and said the administration was working on an executive order related to election integrity — comments framed as a response to the special-election vote. Proposition 50 would temporarily shift power to redraw congressional districts to the California Legislature, producing a map that many analysts describe as favorable to Democrats and adopted amid a national fight over mid-decade redistricting after Republican-led maps in Texas. California Governor Gavin Newsom and Secretary of State Shirley Weber rejected the president's fraud claims; Weber called the allegation "another baseless claim" and urged Californians to vote.
Why this matters
Presidential threats of criminal prosecution and executive action against state ballot measures represent unprecedented federal interference in areas the Constitution reserves to states. Trump has no legal authority to override California redistricting decisions through executive action. The attack on Proposition 50 one day before the election appears designed to intimidate voters and suppress turnout through fear of federal retaliation. Both parties engage in partisan gerrymandering, but Trump inserting himself through threats of prosecution creates dangerous precedent for federal control of state election administration. Citizens should demand Congress ban mid-decade redistricting by both parties and create independent commissions to draw districts based on communities rather than partisan advantage.
Core Facts
President Trump posted on Truth Social on Nov. 4, 2025, calling Proposition 50 a "GIANT SCAM" and saying "All 'Mail-In' Ballots... is under very serious legal and criminal review.".
White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters on Nov. 4 that the White House was "looking into executive action" and said the administration was working on an executive order addressing alleged fraud in California's mail voting. Leavitt did not claim the president can unilaterally nullify a statewide ballot measure.
Proposition 50 was a 2025 California constitutional amendment on the November 4 special election ballot that would temporarily return congressional redistricting authority to the Legislature and produce a new map widely described as favorable to Democrats, put forward after Republican-led mid-decade redistricting in other states.
California Secretary of State Shirley Weber called the president's claims "another baseless claim," and she urged voters to go to the polls. California election officials and the state's attorney general's office described the allegations as unsupported.
The Constitution assigns primary authority over the "times, places and manner" of congressional elections to the states and gives Congress the power to regulate federal election rules. Legal experts said the president lacks a clear constitutional mechanism to unilaterally overturn a state ballot measure or take over state redistricting.
Mid-decade redistricting has increased as state partisan control has shifted. Texas Republican leaders pursued mid-decade map changes in 2023; those moves helped trigger political and legislative responses in Democratic-led states including California.
Key Actors
Donald Trump
President of the United States
He posted on Truth Social on Nov. 4, 2025, calling California’s Proposition 50 a "GIANT SCAM" and saying mail-in ballots in the state were under "very serious legal and criminal review."
Karoline Leavitt
White House Press Secretary
She told reporters on Nov. 4 that the White House was "looking into executive action" and said the administration was working on an executive order addressing alleged election fraud; she did not claim the president had constitutional authority to void a state ballot measure.
Gavin Newsom
Governor of California
He defended Proposition 50 as a political response to Republican mid-decade redistricting in other states and criticized federal attempts to intimidate voters; reporting shows Newsom denounced Trump’s allegations but does not support the extra tariff/Supreme Court claims attributed in the original text.
Shirley Weber
California Secretary of State
She issued a statement calling the president’s claims "another baseless claim" and urged Californians to vote, stressing that California’s election systems are validated and secure.
Rob Bonta
California Attorney General
His office's spokesperson said that Trump was spreading falsehoods and that California elections are fair and secure; the attorney general's office would be expected to defend the state's measures in any federal litigation.
Texas Republican Leadership
Initiated Mid-Decade Redistricting
They pursued mid-decade congressional redistricting in 2023, prompting Democrats in California and elsewhere to consider countermeasures, including Proposition 50.
Test Your Knowledge
Ready to put your civic knowledge to the test? Take a quiz on this topic to see how well you understand the key concepts.
Start Quiz19 questions available