Democrats are outrunning 2024 margins by 32 points in special elections
Democrats have averaged a 15-point swing in 15 special elections since January — including 32 points in Texas
Democrats have averaged a 15-point swing in 15 special elections since January — including 32 points in Texas
Democrats outperformed their prior margins by an average of 15 percentage points across roughly 40 special elections held between November 2024 and February 2026. That average is larger than the 10-point swing that preceded Democrats flipping 40 House seats in the 2018 midterms.
Taylor Rehmet, a machinist union leader, won Texas Senate District 9 on January 31, 2026, capturing 57 percent of the vote. Trump won the same district by 17 points in 2024, making this a 32-point swing toward Democrats—the seat had not elected a Democratic state senator in three decades.
Republican Matt Van Epps won Tennessee's 7th Congressional District in December 2025, but Aftyn Behn held him to 54 percent. Republicans won that same seat by 22 points in 2024. Democrats improved by about 13 points in a district that Cook Political Report rates R+10.
Abigail Spanberger defeated Republican Winsome Earle-Sears in Virginia's November 2025 governor's race by 15 percentage points, flipping the governorship from red to blue. She ran explicitly against DOGE federal layoffs and Trump administration tariffs, and her 527,000-vote raw margin was the largest in Virginia gubernatorial history.
In Florida's 2025 state legislative special elections, Democrats consistently outperformed their prior vote shares in districts Trump won. A Democrat took 62 percent of the vote in a Louisiana state House district Trump carried by 13 points, illustrating that the pattern extended well beyond high-profile congressional races.
Democrats flipped 21 percent of GOP-held state legislative seats in 2025 special elections nationally, according to Bolts magazine, which tracked 119 resolved races. That seat-flip rate far exceeds what historical baselines would predict in a normal political environment.
The Cook Political Report's Partisan Voting Index, known as Cook PVI, measures how much more Republican or Democratic a district votes compared to the national average. A district rated R+10 should lean 10 points more Republican than the country overall—so a 13-point Democratic swing effectively neutralizes that structural advantage and puts the race in competitive territory.
Political scientists who study special elections note that no single race is reliably predictive, but patterns across 30 or more races in a short window are strongly correlated with the next general election. The 2017-2018 special election data accurately forecast a Democratic House majority, while 2009-2010 Republican overperformance accurately forecast the Tea Party wave.
Analysts at Inside Elections and Sabato's Crystal Ball estimated in early 2026 that if the current special-election environment held, Democrats would need to outperform Vice President Harris by about 3 points in swing districts to capture the House majority—a threshold the existing special-election data suggests is within reach.
Democratic state senator-elect, Texas Senate District 9
Democratic nominee, Tennessee 7th Congressional District special election, December 2025
Governor of Virginia (elected November 2025)
Democratic nominee, Georgia 14th Congressional District special election, March 2026
Editor-in-chief, Cook Political Report
Founder, Sabato's Crystal Ball, University of Virginia Center for Politics